Is a Diploma in Automobile Engineering Worth It? A Professor's insight

Published On 22/7/2024, 10:34:30 am Author Prof Atanu Banarjee

In my 15 years of experience, I've witnessed the rise and fall of the engineering degree craze due to overcrowding and reduced demand. Meanwhile, the stigma surrounding diploma programs is fading. Explore whether a diploma in automobile engineering is a valuable investment and how it compares to traditional degrees in today's job market.

One of the significant advantages of pursuing a diploma in automobile engineering is the opportunity for lateral entry into a degree program later on. This flexibility allows students to build on their qualifications and advance their education if desired. However, let’s be realistic: many graduates today are finding employment in the IT sector, which often requires only 6-8 months of targeted skill training. I've seen civil engineers landing roles as software development engineers (SDEs) and mechanical engineers working as testers in companies like TCS and Wipro. This raises the question: what’s the point of investing in a traditional engineering degree?

In this article, you will discover:

The Benefits of Pursuing a Diploma in Automobile Engineering: Understand the practical advantages and early career opportunities it offers.

The Challenges of Traditional Engineering Degrees: Learn about the issues related to overcrowding and the value of hands-on experience.

Career Opportunities and Salary Expectations: Explore the potential earnings and job prospects for diploma holders versus degree graduates.

Career Opportunities and Salary Expectations: Explore the potential earnings and job prospects for diploma holders versus degree graduates.

The Role of Vocational Training in Today's Job Market: Discover how practical skills and vocational training can lead to success in the automotive industry.

The software field, which used to be highly sought after with attractive financial rewards, is now facing its own challenges. Much like civil engineering, which was once popular but now has less demand, the software industry is going through a period of adjustment. The fast pace of technological change and the need to keep updating skills can be overwhelming. As a result, many people are looking for more stable and less uncertain career options. Students are increasingly turning to non-tech jobs in areas like operations, manufacturing, and other fields.

Shift in educational trends

In the USA, the value of obtaining a traditional professional degree has diminished over the years. Many people are now finding that a solid high school education combined with some vocational training is sufficient to enter the workforce and build a successful career. This shift reflects a broader change in the job market, where practical skills and hands-on experience are increasingly valued over lengthy academic credentials.

While there are still many fields that require a full-time degree, such as medicine, law, and engineering, this path is not necessarily the right choice for everyone. For many roles, especially in technical and vocational fields, practical experience and specialized training can be just as valuable, if not more so, than a traditional degree.

In the U.S., recent statistics support this trend. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS), about 30% of jobs in the U.S. do not require a bachelor's degree and are filled by individuals with some form of post-secondary vocational training or an associate degree. Additionally, the National Center for Education Statistics (NCES) reports that the number of people enrolling in community colleges and vocational programs has increased significantly over the past decade, reflecting a growing recognition of the value of these educational paths.

Furthermore, a study by the Georgetown University Center on Education and the Workforce found that nearly 60% of U.S. workers with high-quality jobs do not have a four-year degree.

In India, the employability of engineering graduates has been a subject of concern and debate for several years. This issue was notably highlighted by the National Employability Report published by the employability-focused organization, Aspiring Minds. According to their reports, a significant number of engineering graduates in India are not job-ready, which has raised alarms about the quality of engineering education and its alignment with industry requirements.

The 2019 National Employability Report revealed that only about 7% of Indian engineers were considered employable in core engineering roles. The same report highlighted that while there is a growing demand for engineering graduates, many lack practical experience and problem-solving skills, which are crucial for effective job performance.

Additionally, a 2021 study by the All India Council for Technical Education (AICTE) reported that only about 20% of engineering graduates were able to secure jobs in their field directly after graduation. This low employability rate highlights the need for reforms in engineering education to better align with industry needs.

Is Diploma in Automobile Engeering Worth it?

Considering a diploma in automobile engineering can be a smart and strategic choice for aspiring automobile engineers. This pathway offers several advantages: it allows you to enter the workforce sooner, provides a solid foundation for further education, and opens up opportunities for practical experience and self-employment.

Moreover, with the rise of the startup culture and entrepreneurial opportunities, a diploma in automobile engineering can lead to immediate job prospects. Many individuals who did not pursue traditional high school or college education are finding success as entrepreneurs or in specialized roles. For example, skilled mechanics who may not have completed high school are earning competitive salaries by leveraging their hands-on experience and technical skills.

While a diploma may initially offer lower starting salaries compared to a full degree, the opportunity to gain practical experience and enter the workforce earlier can lead to significant benefits. According to recent data, the average salary for a diploma holder in automobile engineering ranges from ₹3 to ₹5 lakhs per annum, while a graduate degree holder typically earns between ₹5 to ₹8 lakhs per annum. However, as professionals gain experience and expertise, salaries can increase substantially.

While a diploma in automobile engineering might start with a lower salary compared to a full degree, the practical experience and early entry into the workforce can lead to substantial benefits. For instance, individuals who leverage their diploma to gain hands-on experience can achieve impressive career growth over time.

Consider a mechanic who starts with a diploma and establishes his own garage. With 10 years of experience running a successful workshop, this individual can end up earning significantly more than the initial salary range for diploma holders. As the owner of a workshop, his income is not only based on a fixed salary but also includes profits from business operations.

In practice, a well-established workshop with a steady flow of clients can generate substantial revenue. A modest garage makes around 25-30 lakhs in revenue every year.

if your goal is to secure higher-paying jobs and advance further within the corporate or specialized sectors, pursuing a full degree and even a postgraduate degree can provide significant advantages. A degree often opens doors to more advanced positions with better salary prospects and additional career opportunities.

So should you do a diploma in automobile engineering? I think you know the answer!